Skip to main content

Log-Structured Merge Tree

Log-Structured Merge (LSM) trees are a fundamental data structure used in database storage, particularly for handling high-write workloads efficiently. Here’s a breakdown of key concepts and considerations when working with LSM storage:

LSM Tree

Concept and Structure​

  • Write-Optimized Data Structure: LSM trees are designed to optimize write operations by writing changes sequentially in memory (to a structure known as a memtable), instead of making random writes directly to disk.
  • Levels and Compaction: Data is stored in multiple levels, and when the memtable reaches a certain size, it’s flushed to disk as a new file (often called an SSTable). As these files accumulate, they are periodically merged and compacted to reduce redundancy, delete obsolete data, and keep read performance efficient.

Write Operation (Write Path)​

  1. Memtable Insertion:
    • Incoming writes (e.g., inserts, updates, deletes) are first placed into a memtable—an in-memory, sorted data structure.
    • Writes are handled efficiently in memory, as they avoid random disk I/O.
  2. Write-Ahead Log (WAL):
    • Before data is added to the memtable, it’s written to a write-ahead log (WAL).
    • This ensures durability, as the WAL records each write operation sequentially on disk. If there’s a system crash, the WAL allows the database to recover any uncommitted data.
  3. Flushing the Memtable:
    • When the memtable reaches a configured size, it’s flushed to disk as an immutable, sorted file called an SSTable (Sorted String Table).
    • This flush process is a sequential write, which is faster and reduces wear on the disk.
  4. Compaction:
    • Over time, multiple SSTables are created, potentially containing outdated or duplicate records.
    • Compaction merges SSTables, removes deleted and old data, and organizes records for better read efficiency.
    • This reduces the number of files on disk, balancing storage space with performance.
  5. Write Amplification:
    • Frequent compactions increase write amplification, as data may be written to disk multiple times.
    • However, this process ensures that queries remain efficient and storage space is managed effectively.

Read Operation (Read Path)​

  1. Lookup in Memtable:
    • When a read request arrives, the database first checks the memtable.
    • Since the memtable is in memory and sorted, it can be quickly searched for the requested key.
  2. Checking SSTables on Disk:
    • If the key isn’t found in the memtable, the search continues in the SSTables on disk.
    • SSTables are stored as a series of files on disk, typically organized by levels or tiers to manage access patterns.
  3. Bloom Filters:
    • Each SSTable has an associated Bloom filter. This probabilistic data structure helps quickly determine whether a key might exist in a specific SSTable.
    • The Bloom filter check minimizes unnecessary reads by eliminating SSTables that don’t contain the requested key.
  4. Searching SSTables:
    • If the Bloom filter indicates that a key might exist in an SSTable, the database reads the relevant SSTable(s).
    • Within each SSTable, data is sorted, allowing binary search, which is efficient for finding keys.
  5. Merging Results:
    • In cases where the key exists in multiple SSTables (due to updates or deletes), the database merges the results, applying any updates or deletes as necessary.
    • The latest version of the record is returned to the user.
  6. Read Amplification:
    • Searching across multiple SSTables can lead to read amplification, meaning the system may need to access several files to retrieve a single record.
    • Compaction mitigates this by merging SSTables over time, reducing the number of files that must be checked for each read.

Compaction​

  • Purpose: Compaction merges multiple SSTables into fewer files, removing deleted or outdated entries and thus reducing storage overhead.
  • Strategies:
    • Leveling: SSTables are organized into levels, and compaction involves moving data from one level to the next.
    • Size-Tiered: Smaller SSTables are periodically merged into larger ones, grouping similar data together to improve access patterns.

Performance Characteristics​

  • Efficient Writes: LSM trees are excellent for high-throughput writes, as they avoid random I/O by writing data in a log-structured fashion.
  • Read Amplification: Due to multiple levels and compaction, LSM trees can have higher read amplification, meaning reads may need to access several files to retrieve a single key.
  • Write Amplification: Frequent compaction results in write amplification, which is a trade-off for achieving better read performance over time.

Use Cases​

  • High-Write Workloads: LSM trees are ideal for applications with high write demands, like logging, metrics storage, and real-time data analytics.
  • NoSQL Databases: Popular databases like Cassandra, HBase, and RocksDB leverage LSM trees for their storage engines due to their write-optimized design.

Considerations and Trade-Offs​

  • Storage Overhead: Frequent flushing and multiple levels of data storage can result in significant storage overhead.
  • Latency Variability: Compaction can cause spikes in latency, as it is a resource-intensive operation.
  • Configuration Complexity: Balancing compaction frequency, SSTable size, and the number of levels is crucial for optimizing performance in an LSM-based database system.

Alternatives and Comparisons​

  • B-Trees: Unlike LSM trees, B-trees optimize for read-heavy workloads by storing data in a hierarchical structure that allows efficient random reads but requires more random I/O for writes.
  • Hybrid Approaches: Some databases, like MongoDB, offer hybrid options to use either B-trees or LSM-based storage, allowing flexibility based on the workload.

MemTable Data Structure​

The MemTable, an in-memory structure, is optimized for fast writes and efficient lookups. It typically uses:

  • Red-Black Tree or AVL Tree: Balanced binary search trees like red-black trees or AVL trees are commonly used for the MemTable. They keep data sorted, allowing efficient in-order traversal and enabling fast reads and writes (in (O(log n)) time).
  • Skip List: Some implementations use skip lists as an alternative to trees, especially in write-heavy databases. Skip lists provide probabilistically balanced structure, making inserts, deletes, and lookups efficient (also (O(log n)) time complexity) while being simpler to implement and manage in concurrent environments.

SSTable Data Structure​

An SSTable, a file stored on disk, is an immutable and sorted structure optimized for sequential read and efficient range queries. Its core components include:

  • Sorted Array (or Block-Ordered Data):
    • Each SSTable is essentially a sorted array of key-value pairs or records stored sequentially on disk. The entire structure is sorted by keys, allowing efficient binary search within blocks.
    • Indexing by Key: Often, SSTables include a simple index (usually loaded into memory) that allows quick lookups by pointing to blocks or offsets within the file for a given key.
  • Data Blocks:
    • SSTables are divided into data blocks (often 4 KB or 8 KB in size), each containing a subset of sorted records.
    • Block-Based Indexing: To reduce I/O operations, an in-memory index is maintained for each SSTable. It contains pointers to the beginning of each block within the SSTable, allowing faster access to specific blocks on disk.
  • Bloom Filter:
    • SSTables often include a Bloom filter, stored in memory, to quickly check if a specific key might be present in the SSTable.
    • This filter allows the system to skip unnecessary I/O operations by eliminating SSTables that definitely don’t contain the queried key.

LSM Tree Examples​

Key-Value and NoSQL Databases​

  1. Cassandra

    • Type: Distributed NoSQL database.
    • Usage: Cassandra is known for its high write and read scalability, making it a popular choice for applications that require high availability and massive amounts of data.

  2. HBase

    • Type: Columnar NoSQL database built on top of Hadoop.
    • Usage: Used for managing large amounts of sparse data, HBase uses LSM trees to support fast writes and high data throughput.

  3. RocksDB

    • Type: Embedded key-value store.
    • Usage: Optimized for fast storage with LSM trees, RocksDB is used within larger systems (like MySQL or Kafka) to provide efficient storage and is popular in storage-heavy applications.

  4. LevelDB

    • Type: Embedded key-value store (developed by Google).
    • Usage: Uses LSM trees to support fast write operations. It’s often used in desktop and mobile applications due to its simplicity and lightweight design.

  5. ScyllaDB

    • Type: NoSQL database (Cassandra-compatible).
    • Usage: ScyllaDB is designed for high-performance and low-latency workloads. It uses LSM trees along with a unique architecture that optimizes it for modern hardware.

  6. DynamoDB (Amazon)

    • Type: Fully managed NoSQL database by AWS.
    • Usage: DynamoDB is often backed by an LSM-like storage engine optimized for high-write and low-latency applications in a fully managed cloud environment.

  7. Bigtable (Google)

    • Type: Columnar NoSQL database (managed service on GCP).
    • Usage: Known for its scalability and high throughput, Bigtable is used for time-series data, IoT data, and analytical workloads that require efficient write capabilities.

Relational Databases​

  1. MyRocks (MySQL with RocksDB)

    • Type: Relational database (MySQL variant).
    • Usage: MyRocks is a MySQL storage engine using RocksDB (which uses LSM trees). It’s designed for high-write applications where reducing storage space and write amplification is critical.

  2. CockroachDB

    • Type: Distributed SQL database.
    • Usage: Uses LSM trees for its storage layer to manage distributed data, allowing it to handle heavy write operations and maintain high availability across regions.

  3. TiDB

    • Type: Distributed SQL database.
    • Usage: TiDB uses an LSM-based storage layer (with RocksDB or TiKV) for high-performance and distributed data management, balancing SQL compatibility with NoSQL performance.

3. Time-Series Databases​

  1. InfluxDB

    • Type: Time-series database.
    • Usage: Known for handling high-throughput time-series data, InfluxDB uses an LSM-based storage engine to optimize for frequent writes typical in monitoring, IoT, and analytics applications.

  2. TimescaleDB

    • Type: Time-series database built on PostgreSQL.
    • Usage: While PostgreSQL uses a B-tree structure by default, TimescaleDB includes LSM options and optimizations for handling high-frequency data insertions in time-series data.

4. Search and Logging Databases​

  1. Elasticsearch

    • Type: Search and analytics engine.
    • Usage: While Elasticsearch primarily uses inverted indices, its underlying data storage and segment merging incorporate LSM-like principles to handle high-ingest data efficiently.

  2. Splunk

    • Type: Logging and analytics platform.
    • Usage: Splunk uses an LSM-inspired model for its data storage to support high-speed log ingestion and indexing, essential for real-time analytics and monitoring.

  3. Log-Structured File Systems (e.g., OpenTSDB)

    • Type: Time-series storage on HBase.
    • Usage: OpenTSDB leverages HBase's LSM tree structure to store and retrieve large volumes of time-series data for metrics tracking and monitoring purposes.